I have come to realize that as a little girl I had a complicated doll history. A child of the fifties, there were a slew of iconic dolls that came on the market in that decade and the next. Betsy Wetsy who if you poured water in her mouth she “wetsied” in her diaper or on minature toilet you could purchase as an accessory. Tiny Tears, as the name implies, cried real tears if supplied by water poured in a hole in the back of her head. Other options were Chatty Cathy who talked up a blue streak if you pulled a string in her back and the first cloth bodied doll, Baby Dear, who had plastic limbs and head but could be snuggled and hugged with her cushiony torso. Later, Betsy McCall came along with bendable limbs fashioned after the McCalls magazine’s famous paper dolls.
As the youngest of the family as well as ten years after the eldest, a son, you might suspect I owned them all. Or at least one. Or none. No, my mama, whose kind heart was no doubt more concerned about saving the world than following doll trends, chose for my Christmas gift at around age five, Poor Pitiful Pearl. Yes, you read it correctly. That was her name and she had looks to match.
She arrived in a tattered patched dress replete with worn black knee-high socks and a red bandana to cover her uneven bangs and tangled hair. But not to fret, included in the box was a a party frock and shiny Mary Janes. The small print in the bubble beside Pearl as pitiful says, “Help, I need a Mommy!” and on the right, dressed in the provided party dress, Pearl pleads, “Change me from pitiful to pretty.” So where do I begin?
Compared to my friends’ dolls there was no wetting or crying or talking or hugging. Just a clear message to make Pearl pretty and change her life. The far reaching effects of that suggestion alone is enough to change a young girl’s personal aspirations but being the dutiful child that I was, I did my best to save Pearl. I tried to make her bangs even but nearly cut them to the roots as they were barely there to start with. I managed to get her unkemp hair into a ponytail, changed her clothes and somewhere between trying to make my parents think I loved her and hiding her in the bottom of my closet to escape her haunting face, I lost one Mary Jane and a black sock.
Luckily, Pearl eventually ended up in my mother’s beloved antique toy basket that sat by the hearth for grandkids someday to enjoy. I was relieved of the guilt of failing to change her life trajectory and handed the baton for that duty to the next generation. One Christmas Eve sitting by the fire remembering poor Pearl, we searched among the toys to find her. My sister and I were home with our children who were scattered throughout the house doing what children do as Santa time approaches, being seen but not heard. We found a shoe and Pearl’s head scarf in the basket but no sad-faced doll. Finally we asked the kids if anyone had played with Pearl. All looked befuddled, palms flat, elbows bent at their sides until we heard a small voice from my old bedroom whisper, “I put her in the mailbox.” My sister’s oldest son peeked his head from behind the door and shamelessly uttered, “I wanted her to go back where she came from.” Redeemed, the next generation had the guts to admit what I already understood. Even toys are hard to love sometimes.
A small redemption in my doll collection came when one birthday I received a Barbie. After my friends had owned the blonde cotton candy ponytail version, plus Ken, the car and the playhouse, I finally joined the ranks of Barbie owners receiving the flash- in-the-pan Barbie Bubble Cut. Yes she existed. But she came and went quickly as she had thick course “done once a week at the beauty salon teased hair” and clear gloss lips. Not the signature red pout. I tried to paint her lips with ruby-colored nail polish. In an effort to make it smooth and long, I brushed her hair so hard her head popped off. So poor headless Barbie soon joined the ranks of basket fireside toys.
I won’t go into the gory details of the hard plastic baby doll I owned that had a silver dollar-sized microphone in her stomach that made a mournful cry when you tipped her forward. Soon after she came along her “voicebox” fell out leaving a gaping hole so she became a tiny alien looking thing. Or the Besty McCall doll that had a broken hip repaired with a bandaid so her flexible joints did not live up to the hype.
You may be wondering how I survived a childhood without the requisite hallmark dolls of my era. Pretty well I might say because never having exactly what you want builds character I have heard.
Truth be told, and I admit this with a bit of chagrin, my doll disappointments only made me more of a perfectionist to find just the right thing for my home or closet or go without until I can. I suppose there could be worse mantras. Carefully choosing a few good men vs. endless consumption shows some self-restraint.
But I am not immune to retail therapy. I can roam a store with no intended purpose. Just like the box directed, sometimes on a bad day, I still succumb to dress me up and make me pretty.